Close
Close
  1. #1
    tinton14 is offline dPS Forum Member
    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Location
    Hong Kong
    Posts
    94

    Default Filter choice, B+W or Hoya?

    I'm currently looking for a filter to protect my 18-200mm kit lens since taking shots at night I've noticed reflection from lights on the images. I've been using the cheap filter that it came with when I got it, I looked back and see that it has been happening for quite a while when I was taking photos at night, use to think it was the tripod, but have upgraded to a stable tripod, so that rules that out. I've been looking around and found the Hoya and B+W 72mm filters both similar price and was wondering if anyone has used these and their opinions on these. Is there a difference between the quality of these two filters? What about cleaning these, I've seen some reviews of people complaining about the multi-coat being hard to clean on the Hoya filter. Any information on this would be very helpful. Thank you for all your help.

    Here are the links for filters I'm looking at:
    Amazon.com: Hoya HMC Haze UV(0) - Filter - UV - 72 mm: DBROTH

    Amazon.com: B+W 72mm UVA (Ultra Violet) Haze Filter #010: Camera & Photo

  2. #2
    inkista's Avatar
    inkista is offline Gear Geek Girl
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Location
    San Diego CA, USA
    Posts
    11,162

    Default

    I prefer Hoyas because I trash my filters regularly. B+Ws have better build quality, though.

    But.

    A better filter is not going to solve your flare issue (it will mitigate it, but ...). In that situation, I'd actually take any UV filter off the lens, and use a hood to shade the lens.
    I shoot with a Canon 5DmkII, 50D, and S90, and Pansonic GX-7. flickr stream and equipment list

  3. #3
    Nicole's Avatar
    Nicole is offline Dr. Super Moderator
    Join Date
    Dec 2006
    Location
    Wellington, New Zealand
    Posts
    8,781

    Default

    Yep, I'd just recommend not using a filter at night because it can add reflections. So I totally agree with inkista.
    Nikon D600 | D90 | Sony NEX-3
    Nikkor 24-70 f/2.8 | Nikkor 70-300 | Lensbaby 2.0 | Nikkor 85 f/1.8D | Nikkor 105 f/2.8 VR | Sigma 10-20 f/4-5.6 | Nikkor 10.5 f/2.8 Fisheye | Sony 16 f/2.8 | Sony 18-55 | 2xSB600 | Orbis Ring Flash Adapter
    My Flickr

  4. #4
    tinton14 is offline dPS Forum Member
    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Location
    Hong Kong
    Posts
    94

    Default

    I've never thought about using a lens hood at night since the location had lights mostly behind me and the rest of the lights were from the buildings I was trying to take. I will definitely try taking the UV lens off then. I've read that the cheap filters will degrade the IQ, would the hoya/b+w do the same? Is there actually a difference between a $40/$100+ or a uv/skylight filters in the glass quality and how it would affect my images? I only own the cheap skylite uv filter so I don't really have anything to compare to. Thank you for your help.

  5. #5
    inkista's Avatar
    inkista is offline Gear Geek Girl
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Location
    San Diego CA, USA
    Posts
    11,162

    Default

    Better multi-coated filters won't cause as much flare or lower the light transmission as much as super-cheap uncoated filters--I use them on all my lenses, because I'm a klutz and I shoot outside in dusty Southern California a lot. But it's still adding another piece of glass between the light and your lens. Whether or not you need one or should use one can be a matter of personal preference.

    Some folks prefer keeping their front element pristine, and only risking a filter coating vs. the coating on the front element. Others say that if you pay $1000+ for a lens, why muck up that light transmission you paid so much for with a $40 filter? So, it depends.

    Now, will you notice a difference between skylight and UV? Probably. Skylight filters are colored a slight pink/red. UV filters don't add a color cast.
    I shoot with a Canon 5DmkII, 50D, and S90, and Pansonic GX-7. flickr stream and equipment list

  6. #6
    tinton14 is offline dPS Forum Member
    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Location
    Hong Kong
    Posts
    94

    Default

    Here are two of the most obvious ones, first is with a flimsy tripod when I first got my camera and second was using a steady tripod a few months after.

    lens flare

    lens flare again
    I actually only had a problem with this building, I didn't notice this on the other buildings I was shooting at.

  7. #7
    tinton14 is offline dPS Forum Member
    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Location
    Hong Kong
    Posts
    94

    Default

    I feel safer with a filter on since I've found fingerprints, water drops, dust on my filter after shooting outside. My current filter doesn't have any red/pink color to it, it only says "skylite mc uv" on it. So is B+W a better brand overall compared to Hoya?
    inkista you mentioned the build quality of B+W being better, so why choose Hoya over it?

  8. #8
    kirbinster's Avatar
    kirbinster is offline Always carry your camera
    Join Date
    Jul 2007
    Location
    New Jersey
    Posts
    6,899

    Default

    Bag the UV or Haze filter, just use the hood - you will get better images. For ND or CP filters I like B+W.
    Nikon D800e, D300, D5000, NIKON GLASS 85mm F/1.8 D, 105mm f/2.8 Micro AF-S VR, 70-200 AF-S VR f/2.8, 28-300 AF-S VRII,10.5mm Fisheye, 24-70 AF-S f/2.8, TC-20E III AF-S, Sigma 12-24 HSM, Sigma 30mm f/1.4 HSM, Sigma 150-500 OS, 2 SB-600 Speedlights, SB-900 speedlight, 4 YN-622N transceivers, Manfrotto 190MF3 tripod & 322RC2 ball grip head. - NJ, USA
    Flickr Photobucket
    Ok to edit and repost my shots on DPS forums

  9. #9
    tinton14 is offline dPS Forum Member
    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Location
    Hong Kong
    Posts
    94

    Default

    Isn't UV and Haze included in one filter? or is it one or the other? How does this really affect my images? I've read something about UV not being needed for dslr because the sensor is suppose to take care of that? (not sure since I've been reading a lot on all these and some information to get blurred together) Thanks again for all the help.

  10. #10
    Gold333 is offline I'm new here!
    Join Date
    Dec 2013
    Posts
    2

    Default

    Even though this is years old I had an experience last week I feel is worth mentioning.



    This was at a Holifusion festival last week. (Look it up on google, its the festival where people throw satchels of color on each other.)

    The color is a very fine dust, like flour, it is so fine, like monoatomic or whatever.

    That pic was just after I asked someone to throw the color right on my lens as I and the guy tking this picture shot.

    I have always had B+W on my gear.


    After coming home and cleaning my gear (the equipment was wrapped very well, so no issues.) when it cme to the lens front I noticed very very light colored dust on the actual lens, behind the filter. Well, not actually on the lens itself, but on the plastic frame around it (it's a 16-35 F2.8 USM II).

    Seeing as the 82mm B+W filter was secured on tightly my friends and I were stumped.

    Again it wasn't alot, very very light, like a starburst pattern on two spots around the edge of the plastic lens frame (behind the filter obviously).

    One guy said the dust was monoatomic so a throw directly on the front would actually cause small molecules to pass through(!) the B+W filter (I really doubt that).

    Someone else said that B+W dont use any glue to glue the glass to the metal filter cover so that a very fine dust thrown exactly on the filter could pass through that. That made more sense to me as the dust behind the filter was peripheral and not on the lens.


    Anyhow, it was a minute amount and I have no damage at all. But it is something that stumped me, as I thought that lens filter seals were vacuum tight. A direct throw on the lens at a Holifusion festival apparently tests this to the limit.


    Anyhow, I had always bought B+W thinking that they should be good enough, but now I wouldn't be so sure.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  

Log in

Log in